Utah Criminal Defense

Blog

call/txt (801) 373-6345 contact jake

google-reviews facebook-reviews Avvo-Reviews Lawyers-Reviews

Expert vs. Lay Testimony in Utah Courts: A Guide to Defending Criminal Charges

Understanding the distinction between expert and lay testimony is vital for anyone involved in a criminal case in Utah. Whether you are the defendant, a lawyer, or a concerned party, knowing how these forms of testimony influence a case can make all the difference. This guide delves into the critical differences, the roles of expert and lay witnesses, and their importance in Utah courtrooms.

What Is Expert Testimony?

Expert testimony is provided by individuals with specialized knowledge, training, or experience in a particular field. Their insights go beyond what the average person might understand and often address scientific, technical, or professional matters.

Common Expert Witnesses in Utah Criminal Cases

  • Forensic Interviewers: Often involved in child justice cases, these experts analyze interviews for compliance with established protocols.
  • Memory Experts: Psychologists specializing in how memories form and can be influenced, aiding the jury in assessing witness credibility.
  • Identification Experts: With eyewitness reliability being a common issue, these experts clarify challenges using Utah Rule of Evidence 617.
  • Firearms and Ballistics Specialists: Former law enforcement professionals testify about weapon handling and crime scene analysis.
  • Self-Defense Experts: Often military or police veterans who provide insights into reaction times and the use of force.
  • Mental Health Professionals: Psychologists and psychiatrists diagnose conditions under the DSM-5, contributing to competency and sentencing evaluations.
  • Accident Reconstructionists: These specialists explain vehicle dynamics and crash scenarios, often used in DUI or vehicular homicide cases.

What Is Lay Testimony?

Lay witnesses offer testimony based on their personal perceptions and experiences. Unlike expert witnesses, their opinions must be rationally based and helpful to understanding facts in the case. According to Utah Rule of Evidence 701, lay testimony does not require specialized knowledge.

Key Differences Between Expert and Lay Testimony

  1. Specialized Knowledge: Lay witnesses rely on everyday observations, while expert witnesses interpret specialized or technical data.
  2. Admissibility Standards: Expert witnesses must meet specific disclosure requirements under Utah Code §77-17-13, especially in felony cases.
  3. Role in the Case: Lay testimony often corroborates events, while expert testimony explains complex issues like mental health or forensic evidence.

Utah Rules Governing Expert Testimony

Under Utah Code §77-17-13 (2025), strict guidelines regulate expert witness disclosures:

  • Felony Cases: Both defense and prosecution must disclose expert witnesses at least 30 days before trial.
  • Required Information: Disclosures include the expert’s name, CV, and a summary of their testimony or report.
  • Government Experts: Experts employed by the government are presumed known to the defense.
  • Late Disclosures: While courts often admit late disclosures, they may delay trials or impose sanctions for bad faith violations.

Utah Rule of Evidence 702 is critical to admitting expert testimony.  It reads:  

Rule 702. Testimony by Experts.

Effective: 11/1/2007

(a) Subject to the limitations in paragraph (b), a witness who is qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education may testify in the form of an opinion or otherwise if the expert’s scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge will help the trier of fact to understand the evidence or to determine a fact in issue.

(b) Scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge may serve as the basis for expert testimony only if there is a threshold showing that the principles or methods that are underlying in the testimony

(b)(1) are reliable,

(b)(2) are based upon sufficient facts or data, and

(b)(3) have been reliably applied to the facts.

(c) The threshold showing required by paragraph (b) is satisfied if the underlying principles or methods, including the sufficiency of facts or data and the manner of their application to the facts of the case, are generally accepted by the relevant expert community.

Other critical expert evidence rules are:

Rule 701 Opinion testimony by lay witnesses.

Rule 702 Testimony by experts.

Rule 703 Bases of opinion testimony by experts.

Rule 704 Opinion on ultimate issue.

Rule 705 Disclosing the Facts or Data Underlying an Expert’s Opinion.

Rule 706 Court-appointed experts.

Why Expert Testimony Matters

In complex cases, expert testimony can be pivotal. For instance, a forensic psychologist’s explanation of memory distortion can challenge a key witness’s credibility. Similarly, accident reconstructionists help juries visualize events that might otherwise be unclear. Leveraging these experts effectively can strengthen your defense.

Practical Tip: Always disclose your expert witnesses on time to avoid trial delays or sanctions.

Role of Lay Testimony in Utah Criminal Cases

Lay testimony remains equally crucial in many cases. A witness’s firsthand account of events can paint a vivid picture for the jury. For example, a bystander’s description of a defendant’s behavior at the scene can reinforce or refute other evidence.

When Lay Testimony Suffices

  • Descriptions of events or injuries visible to any observer.
  • Perceptions of a defendant’s emotional state or actions.
  • Opinions based on direct experience, such as a driver recounting accident details.

Call / TXT Utah Criminal Defense Attorney Jake Gunter (801) 373-6345.  Free Consult.

Facing criminal charges in Utah? Understanding the role of expert and lay testimony could make or break your case. At Provo Criminal Defense, we specialize in crafting strong defense strategies that utilize the right witnesses to protect your rights. Contact us today at (801) 373-6345 for a free consultation, or visit Provocriminaldefense.com to learn more.

Is the lawyer you are about to call have 20 plus jury trials? Experience matters in criminal defense. Contact Jake today!

provocriminaldefense.com
call or text

(801) 373-6345

Contact Jake