Utah has quietly added a new wrinkle to criminal sentencing law. The Utah Legislature recently enacted a statute allowing judges to treat the use of artificial intelligence (AI) in committing a crime as a sentencing aggravator. This means that if prosecutors can show AI tools were used to plan, execute, or enhance a criminal offense, a judge may impose a harsher sentence, even if the underlying charge remains the same.
AI use is now one factor a sentencing court may consider within Utah’s already broad sentencing discretion. While this change has not yet made waves in everyday courtroom practice, it represents a significant legal development for anyone facing criminal charges in Utah.
Has This AI Sentencing Aggravator Been Used Yet?
On paper, the law is significant. In practice, it has not shown up in Utah courtrooms—at least not yet.
I am in court somewhere in Utah almost every day. So far, I have not seen prosecutors attempt to apply this new AI-related aggravating factor, nor have I seen judges rely on it at sentencing. That will almost certainly change as AI becomes more common in daily life, criminal investigations, and digital evidence.
Defendants and defense attorneys should expect prosecutors to begin testing the boundaries of this law in the near future.
What Counts as “Using AI” to Commit a Crime in Utah?
The statute is written broadly, leaving plenty of room for interpretation. Potential examples of AI use in criminal cases could include:
-
Using AI to generate fraudulent documents in cases involving fraud or embezzlement
-
Using AI tools to automate identity theft or financial crimes, such as creating false IDs or synthetic identities
-
Using AI-powered software to plan, disguise, or scale criminal conduct
Because the law is new, Utah courts have not yet defined clear limits on what qualifies as “using AI” to commit a crime. That uncertainty creates risk for defendants. Prosecutors may attempt to stretch the definition of AI use, while defense attorneys will need to push back aggressively.
Why AI as a Sentencing Aggravator Matters
Sentencing aggravators can significantly increase the severity of a criminal sentence in Utah. Even when the underlying charge does not change, an aggravator can:
-
Increase jail or prison exposure, or any exposure to incarceration
-
Increase fines within the statutory maximum
-
Affect probation conditions, such as restrictions on computer or internet use
-
Influence how a judge views the defendant’s intent, sophistication, or blameworthiness
Allegations of AI involvement may also make a case appear more complex or intentional than it actually is. For that reason, claims of AI use should be challenged early, carefully, and forcefully.
Accused of Using AI in a Crime? What to Do Next
If you are facing criminal charges in Utah and the government claims you used AI—or you are concerned they might—you need experienced legal counsel immediately. These cases often involve technical issues, digital forensics, evolving statutes, and legal questions that many courts have never addressed before.
Speak With an Experienced Utah Criminal Defense Attorney
Call or text Utah Criminal Defense Attorney Jake Gunter at (801) 373-6345.
I handle criminal cases statewide and can help you:
-
Understand how the AI sentencing aggravator may apply to your case
-
Challenge weak or overreaching claims of AI involvement
-
Protect your rights and fight for the best possible outcome
Do not assume prosecutors will get this right. New laws invite aggressive interpretations—and strong defense advocacy matters more than ever.
Learn More About Criminal Defense Lawyer Jake Gunter
For additional insights on Criminal Defense Law and to get to know Jake Gunter better, check out these helpful videos:
- Meet Jake Gunter – Learn more about Jake Gunter's background, experience, and dedication to helping clients throughout Utah.
- How to Choose a Utah Personal Injury Attorney – This video offers guidance on selecting the right personal injury attorney to ensure you receive effective representation.
- What Jake Gunter Does and Who He Represents – Discover the types of cases Jake Gunter handles and how he advocates for the rights of injured individuals statewide.
These resources will provide you with valuable information as you consider your legal options. For any questions or to schedule a free consultation, feel free to reach out to us directly.